There has once again been much tearing of hair and rending of cloth over another tirade against the evils of fanfiction. Others have responded much wittier and wiser than I could. But let me be perfectly clear on one thing, and I speak for Emery on this as well:
I AM A FAN WRITER.
Most writers are. For a lot of us, the words started coming before we knew what to do with them. For me, it was Star Wars. The Empire Strikes Back came out in 1980, and I was obsessed. I had to FIX it. Han couldn’t stay locked in that block forever, not when he’d just told the princess he loved her! (Sort of. At thirteen, I found it very romantic.) So I did. I wrote the whole first half hour of Return of the Jedi. I’m not kidding. It scares me how many of the details I had actually turned up in the movie, right down to Han’s carbonite sickness. I take it less as a credit to my storytelling skills and chalk it up more to George writing like a thirteen year old girl, which the later series proved out. But it didn’t matter. I was writing.
Once the words started coming out, there really was no stopping it. I did Doctor Who fic and Star Trek fic. (This was before there was a need for TOS tags. There *was* only one series.) I had my first real editing experience on a Remington Steele story I wrote. Back in those days, if you wrote fanfic and wanted it published, you actually submitted it, dealt with acceptance and rejection letters, and if accepted, went through a full editorial process. I was fortunate at seventeen to get a good, serious editor who worked with me and taught me a lot, more than any of the creative writing classes I had later. After three rounds of revision where the manuscript came back soaked in red ink every time, when the finished product finally came out and I held it in my hands, I felt like a real author.
Grad school crushed the creative spirit out of me right when I was trying to make the jump to pro writing. It was almost ten years before I took up writing again, and again it was for fan writing, this time in the Buffy the Vampire Slayer universe. And again, I learned a lot from the process. It was through Buffy that I met Emery, and for both of us it was in the Buffyverse that we began developing as erotic romance writers. Giles/Ethan fic was the first M/M I ever enjoyed, because the ship made sense to me, unlike others in other fandoms that seemed forced on the characters. And by exploring those kinds of relationships, ones that were realistic and complicated and less than fairy tale, I started developing my own voice for writing characters like David and Carver and Peter and Graham and even Diana, bless her inconvenient boobage.
Most writing advice gives the first and foremost advice for a learning writer is to WRITE. Write anything. Write blog posts, write letters, write grocery lists, WRITE ANYTHING. And that includes fan fiction. It’s easy to write what you love, and that makes it easier to write when it’s hard.
Now if you’ll excuse me, I have some Ashes to Ashes fic to work on.